Comment: When religion and sexuality come together - for the better

Sally Goldner was raised Jewish but went to an Anglican boys' school. Here she shares her journey of sexuality, gender and faith.

UK - Culture - Gay and lesbian Pride Parade through central London

Religion and LGBTI come together at Pride London. Source: Getty Images

Right now is a very important time of year for those with a connection to Judaism. We’ve just passed Rosh Hashanah (the Jewish New year) and Yom Kippur, the highest of high holy days, gets underway in the evening of Tuesday 11 October. These days are important for Jewish people; thankfully for Jewish people who are LGBTI and their families they are becoming increasingly a time of joy rather than one of isolation and feeling torn apart.

I would acknowledge immediately that my journey is my journey regarding my faith and being bi and trans. Everyone’s journey in these areas is their own and I affirm that. Personally, I had an interesting journey with my faith. I was a nice Jewish (deep down) girl who spent all of my 13 years at school at an Anglican boys’ school. I received some good messages about Christianity generally and also some good messages at Jewish Sunday school.
I wondered for a long time why the experience didn’t quite resonate for me.
Unfortunately, I didn’t get any affirming messages regarding LGBTI and Christianity while at school. I clearly remember Year 10 (1980) and the chaplain taking the religious studies class. I remember his patronising tone of voice saying “there are homosexuals. These people are sick; they need our help” - not very affirming. And Judaism, well nothing at all - I and all LGBTI seemed invisible.

Thirteen is also a critical number in Jewish life. Those assigned male at birth experience the ritual of bah mitzvah – the coming of age of a Jewish boy into a man. I wondered for a long time why the experience didn’t quite resonate for me.

After beginning to be truer to myself in 1995 regarding gender identity and sexual orientation, spirituality and faith, which had been buried deep down, began to re-surface. The support of the Jewish Lesbian Group in 1998 helped re-create a sense of connection back to my true self. There were only one or two areas of connection with Judaism and LGBTI for almost a decade. Gradually, as understanding progressed, this changed for the better.

Ultimately, it was an amazing feeling in 2014, when at the first Pride Shabbat service in Melbourne I gave a short reading from the scriptures. It was my bas mitzvah – the coming of age of that Jewish girl as a Jewish woman - at 48. On leaving the service, I was told “you are always welcome here.” That I’ve been back voluntarily to the two subsequent services in 2015 and 2016 says something about how those bits of affirmation brought parts of me together. We all need to be whole.
When it’s like that and we can simply live our lives and be our best, I think that’s all we ever want.
I acknowledge many people have felt incredibly hurt by negative messages about LGBTI and faith. Often these messages seem - and are - loud, intense and vitriolic. There are places in Judaism and Christianity where you can be all of your whole self. , for example, can help. I feel for my siblings of Islamic faith that there is still distance to travel. I think that their journey will be accelerated due to the amazing work of (acknowledging other LGBTI people of Islamic faith who blazed a trail for 10-15 years prior in Australia).

My thoughts and feelings about faith today are characterised from this quote (author unknown), of what for me is an unlikely source: the Buddhist faith. I believe it was a Buddhist monk who said: “I carry my temple with me everywhere I go.” My temple is, well, inside my temple. And when it comes to my gender identity, my sexual orientation and my spirituality, my temple is definitely a place of peace and contentment.

And when it’s like that and we can simply live our lives and be our best, I think that’s all we ever want.

 is Executive Director of Transgender Victoria; the views expressed are her own. 


Share
4 min read
Published 6 October 2016 5:38pm
Updated 7 October 2016 6:27am
By Sally Goldner


Share this with family and friends