Opinion: Elections in India and Australia - the saga of two parallel universes

As the citizens of both India and Australia cast their votes, the social, and economic issues at play in both nations are 'not that far-fetched,' writes Sanam Sharma.

Voters que at a polling booth at West Epping Public School in the electorate of Bennelong in Sydney, Saturday, Aug. 21, 2010. (AAP Image/Tracey Nearmy) NO ARCHIVING

Voters que at a polling booth at West Epping Public School in the electorate of Bennelong in Sydney, Saturday, Aug. 21, 2010. (AAP Image/Tracey Nearmy) Source: AAP

For the Indian migrant community in Australia, the first quarter and a bit of 2019 has been infested with ‘election’ fervour. It’s not often that the national elections for both India and Australia coincide. This year though, citizens for both these countries are going to polls in May to elect their respective national governments.

An election in Australia may seem to bear no resemblance with the way the elections in India will be carried out (and justifiably so). India is the largest democracy in the world, and just the sheer number of voters eligible to cast a vote means that the polls are conducted over a matter of weeks. Contrastingly, in Australia, it is will be all done and dusted from dawn to dusk on an otherwise uneventful Saturday (18 May 2019).

If you were to delve a bit deeper, though, the social, and economic issues at play for the citizens of both nations are not that far-fetched (if one was to cast aside the obvious differences between the two economies).

 
Indian elections 2019
A polling officer marks the finger of Indian lambadi tribeswomen at a polling station at Pedda Shapur on the outskirts of Hyderabad April 11 2019. Source: Getty
At the grass-roots level, the broader manifesto in both countries is around healthcare, education, and affordable living. Understandably, in India, the aspiration for the majority of its citizens is to have access to the most basic standards of these needs, while in Australia the citizens seek a more enhanced standard than what exists currently.

Religious affiliations have long played a pivotal (and often an ugly) part in determining the fate of elections in India. The 2019 edition has been no different. In recent times, Australia has been grappling with an undertone of racial and communal tensions which are now undeniably a factor that Australians may take to the polling booths when they cast their vote – although they will not manifest into an election exercise as overtly, and as distastefully as they do in India.

The most glaring parallel though, between the Indian and the Australian election of 2019, has to be the exponentially depleting merit of the broader political class in both these countries respectively. There is a screaming dearth of “leaders” and “statesmen” amongst the political fraternities in both countries, making it ever so harder for the public to choose a government.

Australia has not had a Prime Minister that has lasted the full three-year term, in almost a decade. So as Australians go and vote on 18 May 2019, they are bound to be sceptical about the durability of the next head of the nation they will elect. There is not much that separates the two main political parties in Australia. Anyone who ends up forming the next federal government in Australia may not do so with an overwhelming majority.

 
A composite picture with Bill Shorten and Scott Morrison.
Saturday marks D-day for Bill Shorten and Scott Morrison after a tough election campaign. (AAP) Source: AAP
The sitting Prime Minister and his government (Liberals) have not overwhelmed Australians with their performance and how they have gone about it (infighting and changing their leader halfway through). The leader of the current major opposition party (Labor) in Australia, on the other hand, remains a grossly unpopular Prime Ministerial candidate. Anti-incumbency sentiment towards the current government, rather than his own charisma, maybe his only saviour. A relatively insignificant third front (Greens) has remarkably failed to articulate their purpose in any meaningful way for Australians to try them out (other than a few pockets here and there).

 
Indian election 2019
Source: AAP
The political merit of those contesting the elections in India is not vastly dissimilar as well. The incumbent Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) government in India has been widely criticized for under-delivering on its promises and for failing to curb and contain religious and communal intolerance. The current Prime Minister Narendra Modi still enjoys a loyal fan base but no longer commands an overwhelming endorsement of the Indian public.

Rahul Gandhi, who heads the Congress Party (the main opposition party), is busying trying to reinvent himself as a political leader but remains gloriously unpopular thereby incapable of leap-frogging the Congress party to an election win. Several regional fronts are furiously engaged in forging alliances to edge out the ruling BJP in their respective regions but none is prominent enough to be an alternative on their own.

So, as Indians and Australians go to elections in May 2019, they will not have a sparkling list of candidates to choose from. Yet, these are the very junctures where democracies prevail and thrive. The citizens in both these wonderful nations will cast their opinions, and let’s hope they do so with the clarity to weed out the underperformers, the hate mongers, the mavericks, and the undeserving.

India, and Australia - it’s time for redemption.
recovered_94db74be9aee8d57f9e97d27460bec4c.jpg
Sanam Sharma is a human resources professional, and a regular contributor to SBS Punjabi. He is a published author, columnist, and blogger, who also regularly writes flash fiction and poetry for his blog "Small town boy".

Disclaimer: The opinions expressed in this article are the personal opinions of the author. The facts and opinions appearing in the article do not reflect the views of SBS Punjabi.

Listen to  Monday to Friday at 9 pm. Follow us on  and .


Share
5 min read
Published 17 May 2019 5:04pm
Updated 7 December 2019 6:47pm
By Sanam Sharma

Share this with family and friends